Research Article - Journal of Drug and Alcohol Research ( 2021) Volume 10, Issue 9
Knowledge, Perceptions, and Practices of Community Pharmacy Professionals Regarding Antimicrobial Resistance Stewardship in Dessie Town: Mixed MethodSolomon Ahmed Mohammed*, Abebe Getie Faris, Abel Andualem, Bedlu Linger, Segenet Zewdie, Yeshambel Asmare and Kassahun Bogale
Solomon Ahmed Mohammed, Department of Pharmacy, Wollo University, Ethiopia, Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Received: 20-Sep-2021;Accepted Date: Oct 04, 2021; Published: 11-Oct-2021
Background: The increased drug resistant bacterium leads to an upsurge in morbidity and mortality from bacterial infections. Antimicrobial resistance is a threat to public health. This study assessed the knowledge, perception, and practice of antimicrobial resistance stewardship (AMS) among community pharmacy professionals in Dessie town.
Methods: A community based explanatory sequential mixed method was employed from 03/06/2021 to 03/07/2021. The quantitative method employed a community based cross sectional study design and all registered professionals were included. Statistical package for social sciences version 20 used for descriptive and inferential statistics. Then, a phenomenological study design was for a qualitative study and content analysis was performed.
Result: More than half (67 (54.9%): 95% CI (47.6%-63%)), (72 (59%): 95% CI (50.9%-68%)), and (70 (57.4%): 95% CI (49.2%-64.8%)) of community pharmacy professionals had good knowledge, perception and practice on AMS respectively. Being males (AOR: 2.72, 95% CI (1.20- 6.18)) and monthly income less than 5000 birrs (AOR: 0.21, 95% CI (0.05-0.88)) was associated with knowledge on AMS. Perception of AMS was associated with males (AOR: 2.36, 95% CI (1.04-5.34)). The practice of AMS was associated with male (AOR: 4.09, 95% CI (1.64-10.17)), degree educational level (AOR: 4.09, 95% CI (1.13-21.60)) and job experience less than one year (AOR: 14.75, 95% CI (1.52-142.98)). Key informants stated that inappropriate use of antibiotics resulted in depletion of normal flora and occurrence of a hypersensitivity reaction. Despite they did not participate in any AMS programs; the program must be practiced by all health professionals. They also stated the poor dispensing practice.
Conclusion: More than half of community pharmacy professionals had good knowledge, perception, and practice on AMS. Key informants had good knowledge and perception of AMS. However, they were not practicing rational use of antibiotics. Implementation of AMS programs in community pharmacies, interdisciplinary teamwork, and increased participation of pharmacy professionals in AMS awareness campaigns
Community pharmacist; Antibiotics; Antimicrobial resistance; Antimicrobial resistance stewardship
Antimicrobial resistance stewardship (AMS); Adjusted Odds Ratio (AOR); Confidence Interval (CI); Crude Odds Ratio (COR); Interquartile Range (IQR)
Antimicrobial agents have saved hundreds of millions of lives from infectious diseases. However, treatments are becoming ineffective against many infectious diseases due to the occurrence of antimicrobial resistant organisms . Antimicrobial resistance is exacerbated by the inappropriate use of antimicrobial agents [2,3]. According to the World Health Organization, antimicrobial resistant microorganisms reduce the effectiveness of drugs and prolonged the duration of infection .
Despite antimicrobial resistance is a global public health problem, the issue worsens in Low and Middle Income Countries, as the incidence of infectious diseases is high compared to high income countries [4,5]. In Africa, antimicrobial resistance has already been documented to the pathogens that cause malaria, tuberculosis, typhoid, cholera, meningitis, gonorrhea, and dysentery . Resistance was also observed in Ethiopia to most of the antibiotics mainly, penicillin G and cotrimoxazole, which are used to treat gram positive bacteria. Resistance is also documented to ampicillin, tetracycline, and cotrimoxazole which are used for gram negative bacterial infections .
Antimicrobial resistance has led to an increase in morbidity and mortality rates [2,3]. The problem is multifaceted as it encompasses medical, social, and anthropogenic spheres . Moreover, antibiotic resistant infectious diseases lead to an increase in healthcare costs for hospitalizations, urges additional diagnostic investigations, and treatments [8,9]. The rising infection rates with resistance add to the costs of health care and compromise the quality of medical and surgical procedures provided . The cost is catastrophic as it includes patients, healthcare providers, researchers, pharmaceutical organizations, healthcare businesses and, all policy makers .
Antimicrobial agents play a critical role in reducing the morbidity and mortality infections occurred due to communicable diseases. However, the emergence and spread of resistance to many of these agents hinder their effectiveness . Antimicrobial resistance stewardship (AMS) is an application that promotes the correct use of antimicrobials, improves patient outcomes, inhibits microbial resistance, and decreases infections diffusion caused by multidrug resistant organisms [12,13]. An effective AMS program can reduce the irrational use of antimicrobials, and hence shorten the duration of hospitalization, reduce resistant infection rate, and cost of treatment .
To facilitate these coordinated interventions of AMS, all healthcare providers are encouraged to hold the responsibility of AMS in practice areas . However, community pharmacists are the key healthcare providers for AMS programs due to their extended role in dispensing antimicrobials . Being active members of the health care system, pharmacists should have leading roles in AMS to protect patients from developing resistance against antimicrobials and to establish a good health care system .
Globally, community pharmacists are in well placed positions to execute medication related to stewardship and medicine management . They play an integral role in AMS programs in community settings as pharmacists are providing value added services beyond their traditional dispensing duties and being the most frequently seen health care professional and serves as the first point of contact for the majority of infections which leads to inappropriate use of antibiotics. Moreover, community pharmacists are offering services being liaised between patients and various service providers . Few studies regarding the practice, knowledge, and perceptions of community pharmacists in AMS were done elsewhere in the globe but there is a scarcity of data in Ethiopia. The present study aimed to assess the knowledge, perception, and practices of community pharmacists towards AMS in Dessie town, Ethiopia.
Study area and period
An explanatory sequential mixed method was used. A cross sectional study and phenomenological study design were employed to assess knowledge, perceptions, and practices of antimicrobial stewardship among community pharmacists at Dessie town.
All pharmacy professionals working in community pharmacies of Dessie town during the study period were the source population while registered pharmacy professionals working in community pharmacies of Dessie town during the study period and who fulfilled the inclusion criteria were the study population.
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Pharmacy professionals working in community pharmacies of Dessie town who were willing to participate in the study were included. Unregistered pharmacy professionals working in community pharmacies of Dessie town, pharmacy professionals working as a part timer and will not consent were excluded from the study.
Sample size determination and sampling technique
To have a maximum sample size, all registered pharmacy professionals working in community pharmacies of Dessie town were included. The saturation of information concerning emerging themes on antibiotics stewardship determined the sample size for the phenomenological study. Accordingly, 8 key informants were included. Key informants were selected purposively by the town drug regulatory.
The dependent variables were knowledge, perceptions, and practice of pharmacy professionals on antibiotics stewardship, and independent variables were socio demographic characteristics of pharmacy professionals.
Data collection procedure and quality assurance
The data collection instrument [17,18] was pretested in 5% of the sample size at community pharmacies located in Kombolcha town. The principal component analysis was run to clean data. Knowledge, perceptions, and practice of pharmacy professionals on antimicrobial stewardship were assessed using a total of 7, 8, and 11 questions, respectively. Cronbach’s alpha test was used to check the reliability of the questionnaire and a value of 80.5% was obtained. Four pharmacists who had no working relation to the community pharmacies used a self-administered questionnaire to collect the data under the supervision of the principal investigators. Data was immediately checked for completeness, accuracy, and consistency after collection and kept in a secured place for compilation and analysis.
The semi-structured interview guide was used for the phenomenological study. Initially, the instrument was prepared in English and then translated to Amharic, and finally back translated into the English language. The in depth interview was done by principal investigators for 7 minute-20 minutes. The interview was done in Amharic and all interviews were audio recorded. The researchers also separated themselves from the text by their understanding in a reflective way and transcribed verbatim. The principal investigators undertook the phenomenological study with an awareness of insider bias and professional relativity. They were also practiced non-judgment.
Data processing and analysis: Statistical Package for Social Sciences version 20 was used for data entry and analysis. After bivariate logistic regression analyses, variables with a P<.25 were entered into the multivariate logistic regression and variables with a p<0.05 were taken as statistically significant. A 5 point Likert scale was employed to measure the knowledge, perceptions, and practice of pharmacy professionals on antimicrobial stewardship. On the scale, the scoring for knowledge and perceptions was 1 for strongly disagree, 2 for disagree, 3 for neutral, 4 for agree, and 5 for strongly agree. For practice questions, a score of 1 for never, 2 for rarely, 3 for occasionally, 4 for often, and 5 for always was given. Reverse coding was done for negatively worded statements. The result was presented in the median, interquartile range, and percentage. The overall scoring was done based on the mean score. The level of knowledge, perceptions, and practice of pharmacy professionals on antimicrobial stewardship was dichotomized as “good or poor” based on the mean score.
The original transcripts were translated into English. The transcripts were coded line by line. The content analysis principle was employed manually and all transcripts were read several times to obtain their overall feelings. The presentation of qualitative findings was based on narrative strategy and key informants’ level of education, sex, and work experience were used to elucidate their verbatim portray.
Good knowledge: pharmacy professionals who score greater than or equal to the mean score.
Poor knowledge: pharmacy professionals who score less than the mean score.
Good perception: pharmacy professionals who score greater than or equal to the mean score.
Poor perception: pharmacy professionals who score less than the mean score.
Good practice: pharmacy professionals who score greater than or equal to the mean score.
Poor practice: pharmacy professionals who score less than the mean score.
Socio demographic characteristics
The response rate of the study was 95.31%. Among 122 community pharmacy professionals, 67 (54.9%) were in the aged group of 18 Years-29 years with a mean age of 30 years, 77 (63.1%) were male, and 62 (50.8%) of the community pharmacy professionals were single. Moreover, 57 (46.7%) of the community pharmacy professionals were at degree level, and 43 (35.2%) of the community pharmacy professionals had job job experience between one and four with a mean experience of 2.7 years (Table 1).
|Age of respondents||18-29||67||54.9|
|Monthly average income||<5000 birr||52||42.6|
|Job experience||<1 Years||12||9.8|
Table 1: Socio-demographic characteristics of community pharmacy professionals at Dessie town, 2021 (n=122).
Among 122 community pharmacy professionals, 42 (34.4%) of community pharmacy professionals strongly disagreed on the effectiveness of antibiotics against viral infections, 41 (38.5%) of community pharmacy professionals agreed that antibiotics are useful for bacterial infections, and 44 (36.1%) of community pharmacy professionals disagreed on antibiotics indication to reduce any kind of pain and inflammation. All 8 of key informants revealed that antibiotics are used to treat infections caused by microbes.
The key informant portrayed: “Antibiotics are used to treat all infections caused by microorganisms except a virus. Pain and inflammatory conditions improved upon taking antibiotics”. (Pharmacist, Male, 8) 45 (36.9%) of community pharmacy professionals agreed that antibiotics can kill “normal flora” present in our body, 42 (34.4%) of community pharmacy professionals agreed that antibiotics can cause secondary infections after killing normal flora, 39 (32%) community pharmacy professionals strongly agreed on antibiotics can cause allergic reactions, and 46 (37.7%) community pharmacy professionals disagreed stopping of taking a full course of antibiotic therapy before improvement of symptoms (Table 2). More than half (67 (54.9%): 95% confidence interval (CI) (47.6%-63%)) of community pharmacy professionals had good knowledge of AMS.
|Variables||Strongly disagree||Disagree||Neutral||Agree||Strongly agree||Median /IQR|
|Effective against viral infections||42 (34.4%)||26 (21.3%)||6 (4.9%)||32 (26.2%)||16 (13.1%)||2 (1-4)|
|Useful for bacterial infections||12 (9.8%)||14 (11.5%)||21 (17.2%)||41 (38.5%)||28 (23%)||4 (3-4)|
|Indicated to reduce any kind of pain and inflammation.||26 (21.3%)||44 (36.1%)||12 (9.8%)||30 (24.6%)||10 (8.2%)||2 (2-4)|
|Kill “normal flora” present in our body.||15 (12.3%)||26 (21.3%)||14 (11.5%)||45 (36.9%)||22 (18%)||4 (2-4)|
|Cause secondary infections after killing normal flora present in our body.||12 (9.8%)||14 (11.5%)||29 (23.8%)||42 (34.4%)||25 (20.5%)||4 (3-4)|
|Can cause allergic reactions.||17 (13.9%)||17 (13.9%)||13 (10.7%)||36 (29.5%)||39 (32%)||4 (2-5)|
|Misuse of antibiotics can lead to a loss of sensitivity to a specific pathogen.||16 (13.1%)||18 (14.8%)||16 (13.1%)||40 (32.8%)||32 (26.2%)||4 (2-5)|
|If symptoms improve before the full course of therapy is completed, you can stop taking it.||46 (37.7%)||28 (23%)||18 (14.8%)||18 (14.8%)||12 (9.8%)||2 (1-3)|
Table 2: Knowledge of community pharmacy professionals on AMS at Dessie town, 2021 (n=122).
This finding was further substantiated by 36 years old female pharmacist: ”Long term and higher dose use of antibiotics will reduce the level of normal flora in our body. Hence, the patient is more vulnerable to develop secondary infections”. (Pharmacist, Female, 5)
Concerning the occurrence of hypersensitivity reactions, one of the key informants explained that: “The type of antibiotics and the genetics of patients determine the occurrence of allergy. Multiple uses of broad spectrum antibiotics increase the occurrence of a hypersensitivity reaction”. (Druggist, Male, 6)
All key informants (8) mentioned that the patient should not stop the medications even if the symptoms disappear. It is substantiated by one of the key informants: ”Even though the patient had symptomatic improvement, patients should take the full course of antibiotic therapy to eradicate microorganisms. Improper use of antibiotics will result in the reoccurrence of infection, an increase in the cost of therapy, and the emergence of antimicrobial resistance”. (Pharmacist, Male, 10)
IQR: Interquartile range
47 (38.5%) of the community pharmacy professionals agreed that AMS programs can improve patient care, 54 (44.3%) of community pharmacy professionals agreed on AMS program incorporation at the community pharmacy level, and 53 (43.4%) of community pharmacy professionals agreed on the provision of adequate training on antimicrobial use to community pharmacists. Nearly one third (34.4%) of community pharmacy professionals strongly disagreed on prescribing physicians are the only professionals who need to understand antimicrobial stewardship (Table 3). More than half (72 (59%): 95% CI (50.9%- 68%)) of community pharmacy professionals had a good perception of AMS.
|Variable||Strongly disagree||Disagree||Neutral||Agree||Strongly agree||Median /IQR|
|AMS programs improve patient care||10 (8.2%)||11 (9.0%)||26 (21.3%)||47 (38.5%)||28 (23%)||4 (3-4)|
|AMS should be incorporated at the community-pharmacy level.||7 (5.7%)||19 (15.6%)||22 (18%)||54 (44.3%)||20 (16.4%)||4 (3-4)|
|AMS programs reduce problems of antimicrobial resistance.||5 (4.1%)||19 (15.6%)||23 (18.9%)||44 (36.1%)||31 (25.4%)||4 (3-5)|
|Adequate training on antimicrobial use should be provided to community pharmacists.||2 (1.6%)||13 (10.7%)||22 (18%)||53 (43.4%)||32 (26.2%)||4 (3-5)|
|Relevant conferences, workshops, and other educational activity are required to be attended by community pharmacists to enhance understanding of antimicrobial stewardship.||7 (5.7%)||10 (8.2%)||23 (18.9%)||53 (43.4%)||29 (23.8%)||4 (3-4)|
|Individual efforts at antimicrobial stewardship have minimal impact on the antimicrobial-resistance problem||12 (9.8%)||20 (16.4%)||40 (32.8%)||40 (32.8%)||10 (8.2%)||3 (2-4)|
|I think that prescribing physicians are the only professionals who need to understand antimicrobial stewardship.||42 (34.4%)||28 (23%)||15 (12.3%)||24 (19.7%)||13 (10.7)||2 (1-4)|
|Pharmacists have a responsibility to take a prominent role in antimicrobial stewardship and infection-control programs in the health system.||2 (2.5%)||16 (13.1%)||19 (15.6%)||42 (34.4%)||42 (34.4%)||4 (3-5)|
Table 3: Perception of community pharmacy professionals towards AMS at Dessie town, 2021 (n=122).
For the promotion of appropriate use of drugs, AMS should be incorporated at the community pharmacy level. This was supported by one of the key informants: “AMS program improves rational use of antibiotics. Thus, the program must be practiced in all community pharmacies”. (Pharmacist, Female, 4) The majority of key informants believed that AMS is the responsibility of all health care providers. Individual efforts in combating microbial resistance will not be continued. This was further substantiated by one of the key informants: “All health professionals have a role in AMS. However, pharmacy professionals should play pivotal role prevention of antimicrobial resistance. Individual efforts of pharmacists against antimicrobial resistance are not sustainable as professionals might be tired off. Teamwork is better to reduce antimicrobial resistance”. (Pharmacist, Male, 7) (Table 4).
|I dispense antimicrobial on prescription with complete clinical information.||15 (12.3%)||16 (13.1%)||22 (18%)||42 (34.4%)||27 (22.1%)||4 (2-4)|
|I dispense antimicrobials without a prescription||35 (28.7%)||28 (23%)||27 (22.1%)||17 (13.9%)||15 (12.3%)||2 (1-4)|
|I dispense antimicrobials for durations longer than prescribed by the physician on patient request.||41 (33.6%)||27 (22.1%)||24 (19.7%)||18 (14.8%)||12 (9.8%)||2 (1-3.25)|
|I screen antimicrobial prescriptions in accordance with local guidelines before dispensing||12 (9.8%)||23 (18.9%)||34 (27.9%)||30 (24.6%)||23 (18.9%)||3 (2-4)|
|I collaborate with other health professionals on infection control and antimicrobial stewardship||10 (8.2%)||17 (13.9%)||30 (24.6%)||46 (37.7%)||19 (15.6%)||4 (3-4)|
|I communicate with prescribers if I am unsure about the appropriateness of an antibiotic prescription||10 (8.2%)||4 (3.3%)||35 (28.7%)||38 (31.1%)||35 (28.7%)||4 (3-5)|
|I have sought additional clinical information (eg, drug interaction, adverse drug reactions, and allergy) before deciding to dispense the antibiotic prescribed.||12 (9.8%)||18 (14.8%)||31 (25.4%)||37 (30.3%)||24 (19.7%)||3.5 (2.75-4)|
|I take part in antimicrobial-awareness campaigns to promote the optimal use of antimicrobials.||13 (10.7%)||16 (13.1%)||36 (29.5%)||43 (35.2%)||14 (11.5%)||3 (3-4)|
|I educate patients on the use of antimicrobials and resistance-related issues||10 (8.2%)||11 (9%)||37 (30.3%)||48 (39.3%)||16 (13.1%)||4 (3-4)|
|I make efforts to prevent or reduce the transmission of infections within the community||12 (9.8%)||17 (13.9%)||32 (26.2%)||46 (37.7%)||15 (12.3%)||3.5 (3-4)|
|I ask patients about their knowledge of prescribed antimicrobials and their usage.||19 (15.6%)||16 (13.1%)||29 (23.8%)||38 (31.1%)||20 (16.4%)||3 (2-4)|
Table 4: Practices of community pharmacy professionals regarding AMS at Dessie town, 2021 (n=122).
Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that the knowledge of community pharmacy professionals on AMS was associated with sex and monthly income. Males had 2.72 times (AOR: 2.72, 95% CI (1.20-6.18)) good knowledge than females on AMS. Community pharmacy professionals with a monthly income of fewer than 5000 birrs had 79% less (AOR: 0.21, 95% CI (0.05-0.88)) knowledge than those greater than 10000 birrs. The perception of community pharmacy professionals on AMS was associated with the sex of professionals. Males had 2.36 times (AOR: 2.36, 95% CI (1.04-5.34)) good perception than females on AMS. The practices of community pharmacy professionals regarding AMS were related to sex, educational level, and job experience. Male community pharmacy professionals had 4.09 times (AOR: 4.09, 95% CI (1.64-10.17)) good AMS practice than females. Community pharmacy professionals with degree educational level had 4.95 times (AOR: 4.09, 95% CI (1.13-21.60)) good AMS practice than MSC level pharmacists. Community pharmacy professionals with job experience of less than one year had 14.75 times (AOR: 14.75, 95% CI (1.52-142.98)) good AMS practice than those with greater than 10 years of experience (Table 5).
|Variables||Poor||Good||COR (95%CI)||AOR (95%CI)||P-value|
|Sexa||Male||27||50||3.05 (1.42-6.54)||2.72 (1.20-6.18)||0.01|
|Monthly incomea||<5000||29||23||0.17 (0.04-0.66)||0.21 (0.05-0.88)||0.03|
|5000-10000||23||30||0.28 (0.07-1.08)||0.26 (0.06-1.05)||0.05|
|Sexb||Male||24||53||3.02 (1.40-6.48)||2.36 (1.04-5.34)||0.03|
|Job experienceb||Less than 1||5||7||0.46 (0.11-1.89)||0.52 (0.12-2.17)||0.37|
|1-4||24||19||0.26 (0.09-0.71)||0.36 (0.12-1.05)||0.06|
|5-9||13||22||0.56 (0.19-1.61)||0.59 (0.20-1.72)||0.33|
|Greater than 10||8||24||1||1|
|Sexc||Male||25||52||3.12 (1.45-6.69)||4.09 (1.64-10.17)||0.02|
|Educational levelc||Diploma||23||30||3.91 (0.95-16.10)||4.43 (0.95-20.53)||0.05|
|Degree||20||37||5.55 (1.34-22.85)||4.95 (1.13-21.60)||0.03|
|Job experiencec||Less than 1||1||11||12.46 (1.43-108.27)||14.75 (1.52-142.98)||0.02|
|1-4||21||22||1.18 (0.47-2.98)||1.81 (0.60-5.45)||0.29|
|5-9||13||22||1.91 (0.72-5.08)||2.12 (0.73-6.16)||0.16|
|Greater than 10||17||15||1||1|
Table 5: Factors associated with knowledge, perception, and practice of community pharmacy professionals on AMS, (n=122).
AOR=adjusted odds ratio, COR=crude odds ratio, CI=- Confidence interval
aFactors associated with knowledge on AMS
bFactors associated with perception on AMS
cFactors associated with practice on AMS
This study assessed the knowledge, perception, and practices of community pharmacists towards AMS in Dessie town, Ethiopia with acceptable internal consistency. The present study revealed that more than half (67 (54.9%): 95% CI (47.6%-63%)) of community pharmacy professionals had good knowledge of AMS. The proportion of community pharmacists who had good knowledge was lower than in Pakistan where 80% agreed or strongly agreed that they had sufficient knowledge on how to use antibiotics rationally . The findings of the survey in Italy demonstrated that pharmacists’ knowledge regarding the overuse of antibiotics as the main cause of antibiotic resistance is lacking . Another study in Pakistan also reported the limited knowledge of community pharmacists about AMS . The qualitative study also identified a minor knowledge gap among key informants. A systematic review showed that community pharmacists had little understanding in dispensing antibiotics, managing infections, and providing patient care . The difference might be due to the differences in the study area. This inadequate knowledge could be attributed to a lack of information being disseminated to the public . Different appropriate actions that would help to improve their knowledge should be taken to rationalize future antimicrobial use.
The present study reported that more than half (72 (59%): 95% CI (50.9%-68%)) of community pharmacy professionals had a good perception of AMS. A study in Pakistan reported some gaps in perceptions of community pharmacists regarding AMS . While another study from Pakistan revealed positive perceptions of community pharmacists on AMS . Key informants also portrayed the importance of AMS in reducing antimicrobial resistance and the leading role of community pharmacy professionals. The behavior of patients and the social environment might contribute to irrational antimicrobial use and subsequent development of resistance . Educational training and communication initiatives on antibiotic use and antibiotic resistance must be incorporated into their activity and that they could play an important role .
70 (57.4%): 95% CI (49.2%-64.8%) of community pharmacy professionals in this study had a good practice on AMS. The practices of community pharmacists regarding AMS programs in Pakistan are poor , where more than half of community pharmacists (59.9%) often/always dispense antimicrobials without a prescription .
The qualitative study also identified minor practice gaps among key informants. Being a developing country, many cases of antimicrobial resistance might be due to irrational use. Such irrational dispensing might be the result of a thirst for financial incentives and business orientations [22,23]. Thus, better education is required on antibiotic use and on the risks of antibiotic resistance to improve their practice .
Our findings suggest that most pharmacists agreed that AMS programs in community pharmacies would help to reduce the inappropriate use of antibiotics. Pharmacists in Pakistan have a positive practice toward antimicrobial stewardship . The AMS program was pinpointed by key informants for reducing the progress of antimicrobial resistance. The implementation of AMS programs is essential in community pharmacists to promote appropriate antimicrobial use as the majority of antimicrobials are being prescribed and dispensed in the community . Furthermore, the AMS program is dedicated to regulating antimicrobials usage to prevent resistance to antimicrobials and hence to reduce the burden on the health care system . Strong physician community pharmacist collaboration is a fundamental strategy to develop sustainable AMS interventions in the community . However, pharmacists play a vital role in combating and preventing infectious diseases . Proper implementation of AMS will optimize the treatment of infections and reduce adverse events associated with antibiotic use . The program also reduces the costs associated with managing infections .
Males had 2.72 times (AOR: 2.72, 95% CI (1.20-6.18)) good knowledge than females on AMS. In Italy, males were more likely to know that the overuse of antibiotics causes antibiotic resistance (19). In this study, male community pharmacy professionals had 4.09 times (AOR: 4.09, 95% CI (1.64-10.17)) good AMS practice than females. A study done in Pakistan revealed that male sex (OR 0.204, 95% CI 0.104−0.4) was associated with poor practices regarding AMS .
Community pharmacy professionals with job experience of less than one year had 14.75 times (AOR: 14.75, 95% CI (1.52-142.98)) good AMS practice than those with greater than 10 years of experience. In Italy, those who have been practicing for a higher number of years were more likely to have better practice  and less than a year of experience (OR 0.197, 95% CI 0.083−0.468) was associated with poor practices regarding AMS . As the experience of community professionals increased, they might be tired off and give up on service provision.
This current study encountered the following limitations. First, the cross-sectional nature of the study design did not enable the establishment of the direction of cause and effect relationships. Second, despite self-administered questionnaire was used to collect the data; some of them might have provided socially desirable responses. Given these limitations, this study pinpointed useful information about the need for more antibiotic education in community pharmacy settings; strong awareness creation, urgent implementation, and follow up of AMS programs and therefore, the findings may be representative of the entire community pharmacy professionals in the country.
More than half of community pharmacy professionals had good knowledge, perception, and practice on AMS. The knowledge of community pharmacy professionals on AMS was associated with sex and monthly income. The perception of community pharmacy professionals on AMS was associated with the sex of professionals. The practices of community pharmacy professionals regarding AMS were related to sex, educational level, and job experience. Key informants stated that long term and higher dose use of antibiotics will reduce the level of normal flora and increase the occurrence of a hypersensitivity reaction. Despite the AMS program improves rational use of antibiotics and the program must be practiced in all health professionals, the majority did not participate in any AMS programs. They also stated the irrational dispensing practice. The problem of antimicrobial resistance can be improved by the implementation of AMS programs in community pharmacists, interdisciplinary teamwork, and increased participation of pharmacy professionals in AMS awareness campaigns.
Ethical approval was secured from the Ethics Review Committee of the Department of Pharmacy, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Wollo University (WU Phar/196/13). Written informed consent was obtained prior to initiating the data. Documentation of the informed consent began by providing information regarding the objective of the study and sample selection. Then, the study participants’ comprehension was assessed using the consent document. The research was conducted after obtaining signature of study participants in the consent requisition form approved by the Ethics Review Committee of the Department of Pharmacy, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Wollo University. Conﬁdentiality of the data was maintained throughout the study.
Consent for Publication
Availability of Data and Material
The datasets are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
The authors declare that they have no potential competing interests.
All authors made a significant contribution to the work reported, whether that is in the conception, study design, execution, acquisition of data, analysis, and interpretation, or in all these areas; took part in drafting, revising, or critically reviewing the article; gave final approval of the version to be published; have agreed on the journal to which the article has been submitted; and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
The authors would like to acknowledge Wollo University College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Department of Pharmacy.
- J. K. Varma, J. Oppong-Otoo, P. Ondoa, O. Perovic, B. J. Park, et al. Africa centres for disease control and prevention's framework for antimicrobial resistance control in Africa, Afr. J. lab, 7 (2018), 1-4.
- S. Mudenda, F. F. Bangara, J. Sitali, M. Banda, Knowledge, attitude, and practices on antibiotic resistance among Pharmacists at the University Teaching hospitals in Lusaka, Zambia. J Harmonized Rsrch in Pharm, 8 (2019), 12-24.
- S. Jamshed, F. Padzil, S. H. Shamsudin, S. H. Bux, A. A. Jamaluddin, et al. Antibiotic stewardship in community pharmacies: A scoping review. Pharmacy, 6 (2018), 3:92.
- WHO. The evolving threat of antimicrobial resistance: Options for action: Geneva: Switzerland: World Health Organization, 2012.
- I. U. Rehman, M. M. Asad, A. Bukhsh, Z. Ali, H. Ata, et al. Knowledge and practice of pharmacists toward antimicrobial stewardship in Pakistan. Pharmacy, 6 (2018), 116.
- T. Alemayehu, M. Ali, E. Mitiku, M. Hailemariam. The burden of antimicrobial resistance at tertiary care hospital, southern Ethiopia: A three years�?? retrospective study, BMC Infect. Dis, 19 (2019), 1:1-8.
- M. Ahmad, A. U. Khan. Global economic impact of antibiotic resistance: A review. J. Glob. Antimicrob. Resist, 19 (2019), 313-6.
- H. Jia, W. Li, T. Hou, H. Ma, Y. Yang, et al. The attributable direct medical cost of healthcare-associated infection caused by multidrug resistance organisms in 68 hospitals of China. Biomed Res. Int, 2019.
- S. Engler-Hüsch, T. Heister, N. T. Mutters, J. Wolff, K. Kaier, In-hospital costs of community-acquired colonization with multidrug-resistant organisms at a German teaching hospital. BMC Health Serv. Res, 18 (2018), 1-7.
- K. E. Thorpe, P. Joski, K. J. Johnston. Antibiotic-resistant infection treatment costs have doubled since 2002, now exceeding $ 2 billion annually, Health Aff, 37 (2018), 662-669.
- J. B. Ndihokubwayo, A. A. Yahaya, A. T. Desta, G. Ki-Zerbo, E. A. Odei, et al, Antimicrobial resistance in the African Region: Issues, challenges and actions proposed. Afrn Hlth Mntr, 16 (2013), 27-30.
- M. Kallen, J. Ten Oever, J. Prins, B. Kullberg, J. Schouten, A survey on antimicrobial stewardship prerequisites, objectives and improvement strategies: Systematic development and nationwide assessment in Dutch acute care hospitals. J. Antimicrob. Chemother, 73 (2018), 3496-504.
- A. E. Alrefaei, M. Y. M. Asiri, H. M. Maashi, Q. A. Bahri, H. A. Sultan, et al., Knowledge of pharmacists about antimicrobial drugs, their perceptions, and practices regarding antimicrobial stewardship: A cross-sectional study in Saudi Arabia. IJMDC, 20 (2019), 30-39.
- S. N. Kapadia, E. L. Abramson, E. J. Carter, A. S. Loo, R. Kaushal, et al. The expanding role of antimicrobial stewardship programs in hospitals in the United States: lessons learned from a multisite qualitative study. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf, 44 (2018), 68-74.
- S. Anthierens, S. Tonkin-Crine, J. W. Cals, S. Coenen, L. Yardley, et al. Clinicians�?? views and experiences of interventions to enhance the quality of antibiotic prescribing for acute respiratory tract infections. J Gen Intern Med, 30 (2015), 408-16.
- M. J. Struelens, Multidisciplinary antimicrobial management teams: The way forward to control antimicrobial resistance in hospitals, Curr Opin Infect Dis, 16 (2003), 305-7.
- D. A. Erku, Antimicrobial stewardship: A cross-sectional survey assessing the perceptions and practices of community pharmacists in Ethiopia. Interdiscip Perspect Infect Dis, 2016.
- M. R. Sarwar, A. Saqib, S. Iftikhar, T. Sadiq, Knowledge of community pharmacists about antibiotics, and their perceptions and practices regarding antimicrobial stewardship: A cross-sectional study in Punjab, Pakistan. Infect. Drug Resist, 11 (2018), 133.
- F. Napolitano, G. Della Polla, C. De Simone, C. Lambiase, C.P. Pelullo, The knowledge, attitudes, and practices of community pharmacists in their approach to antibiotic use: A nationwide survey in Italy. Antibiotics, 8 (2019), 177.
- Z. Saleem, M. A. Hassali, F. K. Hashmi, B. Godman, F. Saleem, Antimicrobial dispensing practices and determinants of antimicrobial resistance: A qualitative study among community pharmacists in Pakistan, Fam Med, 7 (2019), 3.
- S. K. Saha, C. Barton, S. Promite, D. Mazza, Knowledge, perceptions and practices of community pharmacists towards antimicrobial stewardship: A systematic scoping review. Antibiotics, 8 (2019), 4:263.
- M. Dameh, P. Norris, J. Green, New Zealand pharmacists�?? experiences, practices and views regarding antibiotic use without prescription. J Prim Health Care, 4(2012),2:131-40.
- N. T. K. Chuc, N. P. Hoa, N. Q. Hoa, N. T. T. Nguyen, H. T. Loan, et al. Antibiotic sales in rural and urban pharmacies in northern Vietnam: An observational study. BMC Pharmacol. Toxicol, 15 (2014), 1-10.
- P. Viale, M. Giannella, M. Bartoletti, S. Tedeschi, R. Lewis, Considerations about antimicrobial stewardship in settings with epidemic extended-spectrum �?-lactamase-producing or carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae. J Infect Dis. Ther, 4(2015),1:65-83.
- M. E. Klepser, E. L. Dobson, J. M. Pogue, M. J. Labreche, A. J. Adams, et al. A call to action for outpatient antibiotic stewardship. J Am Pharm, 57 (2017), 457-63.
- T. Rizvi, A. Thompson, M. Williams, S. T. R. Zaidi, Perceptions and current practices of community pharmacists regarding antimicrobial stewardship in Tasmania, Int J Clin Pharm, 40 (2018), 1380-7